How Go Fund Me prevents fraud

GoFundMe is a great way to scam people


I'm not the moral police here, but I'll just go ahead and say that people shouldn't cheat on one another. Think of a free world scam! We would love to be the unlucky Nigerian Prince and the Publishers Clearing House to trust. Yes, above all: don't cheat people. It is unpolite. But if you were To perpetuate a scam, crowdfunding platform GoFundMe, a great way is to do so.

GoFundMe is a crowdfunding platform like Kickstarter and Indiegogo. It just has a much looser jurisdiction when it comes to what kind of things can be funded. You can use money for charity or sanctuary to the sick child ... or you can use it to ask your friends to pay for your morally awful sex tourism vacation.

I'm not saying the GoFundMe way of working is to rip people off (or to facilitate morally awful sex tourism vacations). But there's minimal * curation when it comes to the kind of thing you can crowd finance, and because their policies protect organizers more than donors or recipients - sob story succubi are able to scam people over and over again with GoFundMe .

A dear Gizmodo reader experienced this GoFundMe scam firsthand and detailed the company's response in utterly lackluster detail.

The reader, we call S, was contacted on Twitter by a man named Ken Wills, the godfather of Noah Knickerbocker, a newborn baby in need of a heart transplant. Wills was soliciting donations for the baby family through GoFundMe. S confirms that Will's sponsored child was sick and donated $ 100. But he couldn't get Baby Noah's tragic fate out of his mind. He decided that he wanted to actively help raise the family fundraise.

At this point he decided to research the situation more thoroughly before beginning to ask, donate to his friends and connections. And that's when he realized that all wasn't what it seemed.

S discovered an ABC news report on Wills campaign titled "Man Allegedly Holds Crowdfunding Money Exalted in Sick Baby Names." It was as bad as it sounds: Wills would have donated the $ 6,500 to help Noah and told the family that he would instead give the money to various charities, a move that appalled Noah's parents - they had already started planning the money use to move closer to the hospital.

Will's posted checks show his donations to Ronald McDonald House, Boston Children's Hospital, and Wisconsin Children's Hospital. But when ABC News contacted the charities to find out if Wills, in fact, had made these donations, none of them had received checks at this level.

When ABC confronted Wills, his response wasn't exactly reassuring: "Wills said he couldn't explain why the three organizations received so little from him, but suggested his exams have not yet arrived."

GoFundMe is recommended to contact the local authorities. The Knickerbocker family filed a complaint with the Colorado District Attorney about the incident.

S was outraged by the report. He tries to search the Baby Noah GoFundMe page to see if Wills, as he claims, has been upfront about the fact that he should always be giving the money to charity and not to Noah's family. But when he went to check, the page was gone. S expl

I don't know if Ken Wills stole the money or donated it to charity. His charity donation claims haven't been backed up yet, however - and it's not looking good at the moment. What I wanted to determine was did his GoFundMe page make it clear that he intended to donate some of the money directly to charities and not give it directly to parents? Because the impression I certainly had was the money wrote to go to the parents, “S me.” When I went to look at the campaign, it was missing. So I contacted GoFundMe. "

S his messages saved by GoFundMe. "If you would like to issue a scam complaint against the campaign, please let us know and put our trust and Safetu (sic!) -Team to investigate the campaign and take appropriate action, "wrote a" Customer Happiness "representative named Meghan.

"How do I make an official scam complaint if I don't know if I was cheating?" S asked. He expressed the problem of requesting access to a record of the original campaign page. Meghan gave him the same snippet of answer about filing a fraud complaint every time. Eventually a supervisor responds, offers S a refund, but reiterates that GoFundMe would not show him the campaign page.

"After removing a campaign content previously found on the campaign is no longer considered public information and we are unable to share it with donors," wrote the supervisor. She later stated that S would need to obtain a court-ordered subpoena to display the campaign page that he had given money.

In other words, GoFundMes policy organizers privileges over donors to the point where they condemn fraud.

This is not to say that GoFundMe wants to be used as a scam platform. All evidence points to the team really being people who for legitimate reasons want to help money. And society has fraud guarantees: there is a wait before campaign organizers can withdraw their money after they close their accounts. GoFundMe clearly does not warn to donate campaigns "unless they understand and trust presents the cause."

I'm skeptical of crowdfunding campaigns as a general basis - Kickstarter, Indiegogo, GoFundMe and the like are, essentially, advertising tools and machine hype. Everyone should be generally skeptical about crowdfunding projects: they hold up their hands and ask you for money and they are often under no obligation not to provide any real evidence that they want the money to be used wisely. But even if I were a flag-waving fan of all things group girl group, this situation would smell rank as well.

Of course, GoFundMe doesn't prevent all cases of fraud. But the company should keep an archive of disabled campaigns that people who followed those campaigns to track to make sure their money was donated to where it supposed to go. It tries to span a line between transparency and privacy organizer but the balance is off and it falls on the side helping liars and cheats.

Noah's family created a second GoFundMe page that was supposed to help their sick child, but now they also need money to explain that the first attempt was a scam.

It's a story that embodies the pitfalls of crowdfunding. These platforms exist to help people make money, and don't forget that the company can take a cut. They are companies that are built on a reputation for idealism that is often at odds with the way they treat the idealists who fuel their success.

* GoFundMe wrote to me explaining that they do curate their campaigns. "We have a dedicated team of employees who view every single GoFundMe campaign before they go public to ensure they are in accordance with our Terms & Conditions," GoFundMe PR Manager Kelsey Little wrote. Welllll okay. It allows people to inquire about almost anything and then not proactively follow up on how they withdrew money personally, so.

Art by Michael Hession / Screenshot by our tipster

Marathon training & colon; Joining a running club is a great way to train for a marathon

I'm at the end of my training for my first marathon. I make the exercise program run less, run faster and it has been pretty boring so far. When I first told my friends I decided to give my first marathon a shot ...

This plastic surgery smartphone game is a great way & comma; Children malpractice & comma; To teach murder

Have you ever dreamed of being a plastic surgeon? Do you have a vague understanding of what and where are your facial features? Then after "Plastic Surgery Simulator - Surgeon Free Spins," you are already overqualified. Welcome to ...

Blasting a Building In Slo-Mo is a great way to start the month

[youtube] bTUu4ZLtDSs [/ youtube] What better way to ring the bell than watching a controlled explosion in November? Sure there is if the explosion was captured with a Phantom Flex high speed camera at 2,500 frames per second. The S ...

Spotify is it & comma; to kill and that's a good thing

Improve Sony PlayStation immeasurably by ditching its own Music Unlimited service for Spotify, bringing the world's most popular (and arguably best) made-only-on-demand streaming service, the world's most popular next-gen toys ...

It's a good time & comma; to be an animator & lpar; In Los Angeles & rpar;

The Animation Guild recently released some data it had gathered over the years, announcing that jobs in animation are at a record high. According to her, there were more than 3,350 animators in the Los Angeles Guild Court ...

This Danish punk band just went country & period; & period; & period; And that's a good thing

For any band, shifting musical direction is a big moment. For some, it definitely works - could you imagine The Beatles A Hard Day Night pumping out clones for decades? - and for others, including famous musicians, can ...

Q & A? What is a good thickness for the uterine lining to glue for implantation & quest;

Question: I have PCOS and have been trying to conceive for six months. I've been on Clomid for six months. My doctor is concerned that my uterine lining will be so thin when my follicles are to a very good size. She got me on Clomid and ...

This mug maze seems like a great way & comma; Time & sol; spill to kill your drink

If you've got tired of the hundreds of games on your smartphone, here's another way to kill the time on your long morning commute - and possibly even eventually beat your caffeine addiction. This double-walled insula ...

Gwyneth Paltrow speaks marriage to Chris Martin & colon; "He's a good father"

Gwyneth Paltrow graces the September cover of Elle magazine. The actress and mother of two is photographed in various black outfits and is fabulous. In the mag she talks about her new film Contagion, along with her like ...

"It's a & comma; good time to be a tourist here" & colon; Iceland is preparing for sporting glory

Since the financial crash of 2008 this small but resource-rich nation has become bust to boom - and football has lengthened its self-confidence with dreams of victory at Euro 2016 When an Icelander talks about buying a new car or cloakroom ...

The NCAA business model is on the verge of collapse - and that's a good thing

An almost radical court ruling has only one disadvantage: it did not go far enough to get student-athletes to pay for the "amateur" college athletics license issued on Friday afternoon. District Judge Claudia Wilken a potential ...

PSG Marco Verratti & colon; "Diego Costa is a good guy - but he uses warfare - to win games"

The Italy midfielder is telling PSG Chelsea from the start on Wednesday, speaking of his admiration for Cesc Fàbregas, the controversy surrounding Serge Aurier - and his attempts to stop attacking constantly booked Marco Verratti pauses as he ...

Nuclear fusion is a real possibility & comma; propose new models

When new computer simulations go into the real world, nuclear fusion, panning the power source that makes the stars that shine, may be a practical option here on Earth, scientists say. Simulations at Sandia National Laboratories ...

Flower power shows sex is a good thing

Sex can be a wonderful thing. But from a biological point of view, it's a lot of work and not the most efficient way to reproduce. Simply bisecting like amoebas do - a method of asexual reproduction - is much more efficient. So why do ...